Winnie - Thank you for sharing your feedback! We're sorry to hear that the Winter '24 box didn't meet your expectations. Our goal is to curate each box with a seasonal theme that brings enjoyment. Sometimes our offering isn’t quite right for all our members. That’s why we provide a full preview of every item in the box ahead of time, giving our members the chance to evaluate each curation with enough time to skip a box if a particular theme isn’t quite right for them. We appreciate your input and hope we can bring you a future box you love!